Auckland man Wen Han bought a 2018 Porsche Panamera, only to discover it had actually been built in 2015. (File photo)


Auckland man Wen Han purchased a 2018 Porsche Panamera, solely to find it had truly been inbuilt 2015. (File picture)

A person denied compensation after shopping for a Porsche three years older than marketed is interesting the ruling, saying he’s about $18,000 out of pocket.

It comes as one other comparable case has come to mild – that of a $97,500 Jaguar marketed as having a “car 12 months” of 2018, when it was truly manufactured in 2015.

Aucklander Wen Han purchased the Porsche for $47,500 from Sunday Restricted in October 2020.

It was marketed as a “2015 Porsche Panamera”, however was truly manufactured in 2012, in line with a recently-released Motor Car Disputes Tribunal determination.

* Supplier breached Honest Buying and selling Act in sale of $48k Porsche, however refund bid dismissed
* Automotive dealership did not inform purchaser that automotive was a repaired insurance coverage ‘write-off’
* No refund for Auckland man after 2015 Jaguar suffers unexplained engine injury

He has since taken the automotive to a registered Porsche valuer, who had estimated he had spent $18,000 greater than the car was value, he mentioned.


Is the Porsche Taycan Turbo S the final word EV? Let’s take a more in-depth look.

The North Shore resident mentioned on Thursday he has filed attraction papers within the Auckland District Court docket to re-seek compensation.

On the tribunal, the corporate argued the Panamera might be legally be known as a 2015 mannequin as that was when it was first registered.

The tribunal discovered the corporate was technically right, however had nonetheless misled Han and breached the Honest Buying and selling Act.

Wen Han is appealing the tribunal's decision to the Auckland District Court. (File photo)

Chris McKeen/Stuff

Wen Han is interesting the tribunal’s determination to the Auckland District Court docket. (File picture)

Nonetheless, it dominated Han was not eligible for compensation as he had not been capable of show he had suffered loss, the tribunal mentioned.

Han had confirmed Commerce Me listings for different Panameras marketed for lower than what he paid, however the tribunal mentioned they didn’t present a “like for like” comparability.

Han mentioned he was glad the tribunal had dominated the corporate had engaged in deceptive conduct.

“A traditional individual would assume that the 12 months on the [car] rego label is the precise 12 months, however it’s truly not. That’s complicated.”

Nonetheless, the tribunal had not given him any steering on how you can show he had suffered loss earlier than the listening to.

“They didn’t inform me what sort of report could be acceptable, so I ready the report by myself,” he mentioned.

In the meantime, in an analogous case, a person who purchased a Jaguar with a “car 12 months” of 2018, however which was manufactured in 2015, has additionally misplaced a bid for compensation.

Christchurch man Martin Edward Evans purchased the $97,500 F-Kind convertible from Euromarque Holdings in December 2019, in line with a recently-released tribunal determination.

A Christchurch man bought a Jaguar F-Type convertible for $97,500. (File photo)

David Linklater/Stuff

A Christchurch man purchased a Jaguar F-Kind convertible for $97,500. (File picture)

He paid partly by means of promoting a $45,000 Fiat Abarth to the supplier and partly by means of a financial institution switch.

When Evans found the Jaguar had been manufactured in 2015, he sought a refund, saying he had owned sports activities automobiles for 20 years and normally sells them when they’re two to a few years previous.

“Mr Evans mentioned that, following his common follow, he wouldn’t have agreed to buy a 2015 car in 2019,” the tribunal determination mentioned.

The tribunal dominated Euromarque had engaged in deceptive conduct and breached the Honest Buying and selling Act, however denied Evans compensation as, like Han, he couldn’t show he had suffered monetary loss.