From the December 2003 difficulty of Automobile and Driver.

Let’s simply say {that a} man who engineers for himself a $197.2 million retirement bundle as head of the New York Inventory Trade in all probability does not see himself in a Hyundai. So we’re pondering massive this month, impressed by the appetites of Dick Grasso. What’s a great set of wheels for these make-do days when the chauffeur is off?

Has there ever been a greater time to be a fats cat? At roughly 70 massive, we’ve three all-new sedans for 2004, one other that is been properly upgraded, yet one more that was so radically redesigned for 2003 we nonetheless have not, uh, forgiven the maker, and at last, an growing old S-class Mercedes-Benz. God is aware of Mercedes-Benzes do not need to be new to get respect.

Aluminum is trendy this season—two of the brand new guys have light-alloy our bodies. One in every of them even manages to be impressively mild. The V-8 Jaguar XJ8 steps off the dimensions, absolutely dressed, at 3838 kilos. New cash may faux in any other case on this magnificence; the look is an evolution of the svelte form that is been successful admirers because it first appeared on the XJ6 within the late Nineteen Sixties. We should always all age so handsomely.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

At first look, you get extra aluminum in your bucks within the Audi A8L, a hefty 4483 kilos’ price. The truth is, you get extra beef, too, a few of it invested within the Quattro all-wheel drive, extra within the 19-inch tires at every nook, and behold these brake rotors sized to cowl manholes. Fundamental black sheetmetal by no means regarded stronger. Think about the Terminator in a tuxedo.

One other manner of downplaying shiny new money, a minimum of in idea, is to drive a Volkswagen. With chrome VW emblems the scale of salad plates on every finish, the Phaeton feigns humility. Simply do not let anybody close to sufficient to see the opulent wooden and leather-based lining of the passenger compartment. Sure, compartment is the best picture, sort of the final step up earlier than having your individual non-public railroad automotive. Though costs have but to be introduced, VW spokesmen estimate $69,800 for the instance we examined. They usually’re well-known for his or her low-balls.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Over time, BMWs have earned a powerful variety of high spots in our comparability checks. However for its all-new 7-series final 12 months, the Munich automaker abruptly modified its successful method, away from endearing equipment towards an off-putting immersion in management knobbing. The 4.4-liter V-8 is stronger than ever, the chassis packs admirable refinements, however there’s this interface downside. Nonetheless, we fortunately provide second and third possibilities to something carrying a BMW label. Let’s give forgiveness yet another strive.

No one, however, has ever been postpone by a Lexus, besides masochists. The LS430 treats everyone proper. This carmaker places its efforts into creature comforts and hides the know-how behind luxurious leather-based. Though this four-door has been round since 2001, upgrades for the brand new mannequin 12 months embrace a six-speed automated, headlights that time the place you steer, knee airbags for entrance occupants, and elective climate-controlled seats each back and front. For these occasions when Mr. Grasso chooses to be pushed, there’s a fair higher function, the elective Extremely Luxurious bundle, which elevates back-seat lodging to the expectations of any Third World dictator. For less than $11,320 further, why not?

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

After all, dictators are recognized to desire Mercedes-Benzes. And the S430 has been pleasing princes, pashas, and potentates since late within the final century. Nicely, pleasing these prepared to forgo the big-V-8 hustle of the S500 and S600, that’s. Given Grasso’s present employment standing—name him hooted into retirement—we reckon he is in much less of a rush. However the reasonable engine is hardly matched by moderation in value—this Benz is the heavyweight of our bunch at $87,975.

Placing apart the general public pickle he is been in not too long ago, you possibly can argue that Grasso remains to be one of many luckiest guys on the planet. This workers does not select new automobiles for simply any mega-mogul. However inquiring minds insist on understanding: What would Dick Grasso drive?

Very nicely. Let the auditions start.

Sixth Place: Mercedes-Benz S430

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

The clout of the three-pointed star and the upright Benz grille proceed undiminished, however this S-class sedan carrying them is displaying its age. The 275-hp V-8 is outgunned by all of the others, leaving the S430 within the mud in practically each acceleration check, and but forward of solely the Volkswagen in gas financial system. Our 2003-model check automotive was hobbled with an previous five-speed automated; the 2004 S430—unavailable for this check—will get seven cogs, trumping the six-speeds in the remainder of the sphere. The five-speed is sluggish to make part-throttle downshifts if you start to up the tempo, and the brakes appear to disregard a substantial amount of the early pedal journey. Do not hassle me, the Benz appears to say.

HIGHS: The intelligent shifter that’s all the time in manumatic, the best way the wooden drapes in ribbons throughout the sprint and doorways, the lusty observe of the V-8.
LOWS: Obtuse HVAC controls, gimme-a-minute angle of the automated (the brakes, too), awkward driving place.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Nonetheless, there are excessive spots. The good console shifter is within the manumatic mode each time it is in D. Bump the lever left for downshifts, proper for upshifts, or maintain briefly to the best for a fast default again as much as D from any gear.

This Mercedes was additionally endowed with street grip exceeded solely by that of the BMW. Each have been geared up with elective sport suspensions and special-purpose tires. On this automotive, which means 245/45-18s in entrance and 265/40-18s in again, each ends labeled Michelin Pilot Sport. Along with the $5100 preliminary value of the tire-and-bodywork bundle, there’ll all the time be a sure inconvenience related to this larger-in-back tire sizing—the spare can by no means be proper for each ends of the automotive.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

What’s the additional street grip price? Three automobiles within the group stand above the others, having braking distances of 169 ft or higher, and skidpad adhesion above 0.82 g. The grippy trio—Mercedes, BMW, Audi—all wore summer season tires. The draw back is that the tread wears away sooner, and the tires usually are not appropriate for temperatures close to freezing or under. Being a New Yorker, Grasso would want a change of footwear for his northern winters. Even when switching isn’t a monetary burden, it is a nuisance.

The summer-shoes Benz gave a first-rate account of itself because it slipped by means of the lane-change check at 57.4 mph, 1.7 faster than the next-best Audi, and 4.3 higher than the slow-guy Lexus. When pushed, the S430’s steering response had the athletic tautness we count on of efficiency tires. Many of the reward for this automotive got here throughout brisk driving.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

The Benz ranked final for driver consolation—the driving place is excessive and awkward—and barely forward of the Audi for rear consolation. Thigh help again there may be missing virtually fully. And we by no means made buddies with the local weather management.

For a chart-topping $87,975, we are able to maintain our applause.

THE VERDICT: Fading expertise at an formidable value.

2003 Mercedes-Benz S430
275-hp V-8, 5-speed automated, 4333 lb
Base/as-tested value: $73,320/$87,975
Inside quantity, F/R/trunk: 53/52/15 ft3
60 mph: 7.2 sec
100 mph: 18.3 sec
1/4 mile: 15.5 sec @ 92 mph
Braking, 70­–0 mph: 167 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.85 g
C/D noticed gas financial system: 19 mpg

Fifth Place: Volkswagen Phaeton

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Aside from surprising people with its chutzpah—a 70-grand Volkswagen!—the Phaeton widens eyes on a number of different fronts. The inside is magnificent. A lot honey-colored wooden burl so artistically formed! We won’t determine which we like finest: sitting up entrance near the motion because the motorized wood-grain shutters majestically swing as much as reveal the dashboard vents, or lounging in again for correct perspective on the lengthy, curving sweeps of furnishings alongside the flanks.

Or perhaps it is the advantageous chrome detailing of the instrument cluster that fascinates, or the center-stack mosaic of flush-fitting buttons.

HIGHS: Queen Mary detailing inside, jewelrylike instrument cluster, silent operation of powered wooden shutters that conceal components of the sprint.
LOWS: So many seat buttons chasing such an elusive consolation spot, physique quivers observe every bump, having to agree with VW attorneys earlier than making fundamental management changes.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

A few of these particulars look higher than they work. The small gauges cannot convey their data at a fast look. Flush buttons, even massive ones, are tough to search out by really feel alone. The Phaeton scored behind all however the BMW for ergonomics.

The Phaeton is numerous VW, 5028 kilos’ price. By no means thoughts that it points from the identical company loins because the Audi A8L and shares the identical aluminum V-8—it is a metal automotive. Add to that 4MOTION, and the scales groan.

The additional 545 kilos over the Audi is offset by extra energy (335 hp versus 330) and a shorter axle ratio (3.65:1 versus 3.32). They’re neck and neck to 60 mph. The VW slips behind solely 0.1 second and 1 mph within the quarter-mile. On the skidpad, the VW truly outperforms the Audi by a tick, darn good contemplating its four-season tires.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

By a large margin, we disliked the steering. It is mild, which is okay if the trouble builds in proportion to cornering forces. It does not. So you could sandpaper your fingertips like a safecracker to really feel what’s taking place.

One other shock: The journey is kind of harsh, and the physique jiggles after impacts. We could not love the seats, both. The adjustment controls in entrance are advanced, fairly like first-class on British Airways, however not all of us may discover a candy spot. In again, the seat itself is okay, however the seemingly huge legroom narrows to the Strait of Hormuz on the size-12 Reeboks. Plus, the journey is even shakier again there.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Enjoyable to drive? Probably not, however there’s numerous marveling at sure behavioral particulars. You’ll be able to hear, and really feel, the drive-by-wire controller enjoying the throttle even when your foot does not transfer, apparently smoothing the engine’s torque quirks. It is slick at matching engine revs if you lever down a gear. And we will not bear in mind ever shuttling an influence shade underneath a sunroof earlier than.

Let’s simply say this ain’t your father’s Volkswagen.

THE VERDICT: You ain’t seen all of it till you’ve beheld a $70,000 VW.

2004 Volkswagen Phaeton
335-hp V-8, 6-speed automated, 5028 lb
Base/as-tested value: $64,000/$69,800 (est.)
Inside quantity, F/R/trunk: 54/55/13 ft3
60 mph: 6.5 sec
100 mph: 17.1 sec
1/4 mile: 15.1 sec @ 94 mph
Braking, 70­–0 mph: 175 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.83 g
C/D noticed gas financial system: 17 mpg

Fourth Place: Audi A8L

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Fundamental black actually works on this automotive. Let the form speak. It is lengthy and assertive. The proportions are highly effective. These tall wheels, 19-inchers, say quick ahead. Why the lengthy rear doorways? Who’s in there? So mysterious. Do you have to stare or avert your gaze? It is gotta be a film star on the wheel, or successful man—for certain, someone necessary.

Grasso? Let ‘im by means of!

This Audi will get respect, even for these with sagging ballot numbers.

HIGHS: Appears to be like massive and in cost, like Mr. Universe in a tuxedo; eye-pleasing inside, too.
LOWS: A little bit of a ruffian over bumps, adopted by too many jiggles within the physique construction; loads of street noise, too.

You could be pondering: similar engine because the Phaeton, and all-wheel drive… Is that this the large VW in a special shirt? No, neglect that concept. It is a completely different automotive, in each physique and habits. The A8L has a a lot sportier, extra athletic stride. It rides firmly, responds rapidly, and makes jock form of noises over the street. You hear the tires. And the wind. And the V-8 if you leg it. That half sounds particularly thrilling. That is luxurious that is proud to be a automotive, which is completely different from the Phaeton’s manner, which is extra like a fantastically constructed transport container for folks.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

The cockpit looks like a spot for driving. The seat is large and agency and supportive with out being confining. The suspension makes reassuring motions. The steering provides assured path management. The sprint shapes and textures are pleasing. The pc display screen folds away behind a panel within the sprint, leaving no hint aside from the button that can summon it as soon as extra. That is curious, as a result of we by no means discovered a solution to search radio frequencies with out the display screen.

Efficiency, by most measures, was common for the group. Zero to 60 in 6.5 seconds will hold you towards the entrance of most packs, however the BMW, the Jaguar, and the Lexus are a shade faster.

Extra troubling, we expect, is journey high quality. Although the physique construction is completely completely different from the Phaeton’s, they each shake after impacts. We’ve got the sense of some vital mass being somewhat free in its moorings. Just a few squeaks and rattles, too.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

House for rear passengers is excellent, however we favored the Audi seat form least of all. The backrest ramps ahead on the backside, pushing the editorial butt right into a bad-posture place. “Oddly formed” applies to the surface door handles as nicely. The bottom feels angled in a manner that slides your fingers off the deal with if you pull.

Backside line, the Audi is our first alternative as one thing to face beside for images. When the numbers are all added, nonetheless, it earns simply 178 out of 220 potential factors, forward of the VW by a transparent margin however one level behind that German we nonetheless cannot forgive.

THE VERDICT: Stunning to take a look at, however disappointing in dialog.

2004 Audi A8L
330-hp V-8, 6-speed automated, 4483 lb
Base/as-tested value: $69,190/$74,690
Inside quantity, F/R/trunk: 53/54/18 ft3
60 mph: 6.5 sec
100 mph: 16.4 sec
1/4 mile: 15.0 sec @ 95 mph
Braking, 70­–0 mph: 169 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.82 g
C/D noticed gas financial system: 19 mpg

Third Place: BMW 745i

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

This can be a driver’s automotive for geeks with pixel-deprivation anxiousness—cannot bear being out of sight of a display screen (see sidebar,”Who Requested for the Lawyer Display screen”). If it went again to a friendlier manner of coping with folks, we might like it.

It has successful strikes, thanks partly to a powerful engine and the elective $3200 Sport bundle (which features a sport suspension and summer season tires). Path accuracy of the steering is usually superb, however the 19-inch Michelins are pulled off the road by street irregularities. Completely different-sized drivers can all discover a completely satisfied working relationship with the controls. The large, stable useless pedal for the left foot is positioned excellent.

HIGHS: Huge energy if you need it, poise on the again roads, limitless legroom up entrance.
LOWS: In-your-face contrariness of abnormal cockpit controls, bad-dream location of steering-wheel shift buttons, pulling our gaze off the street to take a look at the &@*# display screen

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

By a small but repeatable margin, it outruns all of the others. Zero to 60 mph clocks 0.3 second forward of the second-best Lexus. It clears the quarter-mile 0.2 second and 1 mph up on the No. 2 Jaguar. And it grips the skidpad at 0.87 g, higher than the second-best Mercedes by 0.02 g.

The BMW earned high marks for stopping—163 ft from 70 mph, 4 ft higher than the summer-tired Benz. Gasoline financial system on our 750-mile check journey was 19 mpg, proper on the group’s common.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Trip is reassuringly agency in entrance, and hang-on stiff in again, by far the roughest of the bunch. BMW has gone to an adaptive suspension—street sensing, you may say—to restrict sure suspension trade-offs. In turns, it resists large roll angles, then softens in straights to ease the head-toss motions related to roll-resistant suspensions. We expect that half works very nicely. It additionally does a pleasant job of limiting the influence noise of the tires. However the vertical accelerations felt by rear passengers are simply plain unkind.

We do not assume dignitaries will ever be completely satisfied again there. The door armrests fade away simply on the level the place you want them most, and there is solely a single self-importance mirror centered over the tunnel. It swivels, requiring vanities to attend their turns.

The 745i can also be much less interesting than all of the others in its inside design. It is solemn inside, perhaps even gloomy. The wooden is stained so darkish it masks the grain. The middle cockpit shapes and particulars put precedence on entry to the odious management knob. And the display screen, with its comparatively advantageous print and odd abbreviations, is difficult to decipher, virtually inconceivable with polarized sun shades. Furthermore, it is tediously sluggish to load new menus.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Do you get the concept that is the automotive we like to disparage?

THE VERDICT: So relentlessly high-tech even the dashboard wooden appears digital.

2004 BMW 745i
325-hp V-8, 6-speed automated, 4545 lb
Base/as-tested value: $69,195/$79,145
Inside quantity, F/R/trunk: 55/50/18 ft3
60 mph: 6.0 sec
100 mph: 15.3 sec
1/4 mile: 14.6 sec @ 97 mph
Braking, 70­–0 mph: 163 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.87 g
C/D noticed gas financial system: 19 mpg

Second Place: Jaguar XJ8

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Even after a tough look, it will be straightforward to mistake this for an older mannequin. Jaguar stepped into deep don’t-do again within the Nineteen Eighties when it “modernized” the alternative for the unique XJ6. Sq. headlights? Digital gauges? Crisp fenders? Would-be prospects held their noses. After years of mea culpas and face-lifting again to ’70s grandeur, the just-replaced sedan lastly received The Look again. Now Jaguar restates it in aluminum, with simply sufficient letting out on the seams to get big-car house within the again seat.

HIGHS: Assured in its Jaguarness; mild and agile and fast on its ft, with a cockpit pc that is aware of its place.
LOWS: Steering will get nervous in wet high-speed cruising, there’s a longish pedal stroke earlier than critical braking begins, cockpit is fairly intimate for such an enormous automotive.

Jaguar all the time noticed its automobiles as roadgoing sports activities jackets. An intimate cockpit was a part of the deal, a slim house for the motive force with the console proper up shut, and a low roof. The theme carried on to the rear, type and beauty with 4 doorways.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

The brand new XJ8 is remarkably devoted to that unique thought. The motive force’s house remains to be slim. The wooden and leather-based environment appear shut and private. The market insists on a helpful again seat for its $64,595, and the XJ8 delivers, however there’s much less leg and foot house than within the others. The previous headroom scarcity has lastly been cured, nonetheless.

Although the journey high quality again there may be fairly good, and sound is properly muted, you should not assume, even for a minute, that Jaguars are about again seats. This new automotive by no means forgets its sporty DNA. The steering is mild and fast and really sharp. You level it down the street by intuition, and it is aware of the place to go. It is fast to your spurs, too, full of life, keen. The six-speed flicks down readily. The V-8 reads your thoughts. This automotive feels spirited in a manner that the others by no means match.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Gentle weight is all the time its personal celebration. F=ma isn’t topic to negotiation. With much less m than the others, and 294 horsepower price of F from the aluminum 32-valver, the XJ falls simply behind the BMW in 0-to-100 sprints and within the quarter-mile. On our check journey, it tied the Lexus for finest gas financial system, at 21 mpg.

The cockpit is quiet and peaceable. The physique by no means jiggles. Nothing upsets this automotive, though it does get tentative, even nervous, at speeds nearing three digits.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

This Jaguar has a purity about it that is lacking within the others. It isn’t filled with distractions in the best way the Phaeton is, or annoyances just like the BMW. It is a automotive, with a easy presentation of these issues you could be comfy, and no froufrou. Sure, it scored lowest on our Options/ Facilities ranking. No power-folding mirrors, no “parking help” to sound a beeper as your bumper nears some object.

A gizmo-free luxurious automotive? What a courageous and great thought.

THE VERDICT: Conventional Jaguar taste expressed in Twenty first-century alloys.

2004 Jaguary XJ8
325-hp V-8, 6-speed automated, 3838 lb
Base/as-tested value: $59,995/$64,595
Inside quantity, F/R/trunk: 56/50/17 ft3
60 mph: 6.3 sec
100 mph: 15.8 sec
1/4 mile: 14.8 sec @ 96 mph
Braking, 70­–0 mph: 185 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.79 g
C/D noticed gas financial system: 21 mpg

First Place: Lexus LS430

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

For those who simply walked up and requested, we might say this isn’t a Automobile and Driver form of automotive. However like gravity, the Lexus saved pulling on us. It is so assured. It does so many issues fantastically. It is like the salesperson who by no means quits, and at last, you end up agreeing with him.

HIGHS: Beautiful inside particulars, whipped-cream journey, silky shifts, rear-seat accouterments to dazzle essentially the most demanding potentate.
Tires wanting to squeal, brakes wanting to make large whoa as an alternative of deft modulations, by no means very involving on the again roads.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

The Lexus journey is unmatched on this group. There is a swap on the sprint that allows you to make it somewhat worse if you happen to should. Go forward, if extra sinew within the suspenders makes you assume dealing with is healthier.

For those who actually need muscle groups, go for the game suspension with 18-inch summer season tires. The 17s on the check automotive have been fast to moan when pushed. Skidpad grip was weakest of all, 0.73 g. However do not confuse that with stumbling habits. That is an agile dancer carrying slippery footwear.

It is best that you’ve a light-weight contact on the controls if you hustle. The steering and the brakes are virtually delicate of their really feel. It’s essential to caress them. And if you do, the responses include precision. Nonetheless, this sedan is at its finest on the expressway. The steering is aware of precisely the place straight forward is, and the sooner you go, the extra it locks onto that heading.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Acceleration is brisk: second finest to 60 mph; third within the quarter, at 95 mph, because it confirmed taillights to a few of the 4 Germans. But its gas financial system on our journey tied the Jag’s at 21 mpg, topped the Audi’s, BMW’s, and Benz’s by 2 mpg, and bettered the VW’s by 4. All that plus the sound of ripping silk if you toe into the ability. Oh, sure.

Energy, although, is one thing you’re taking without any consideration on this class. It is the Lexus inside that retains wonderful. Are pleasure palaces this advantageous? The Ecru leather-based is so gentle ($1460). The seat is such an ideal form, and amazingly, it feels that manner for each driver. The wooden grain is so radiant, so expressive, so intricate and self-illuminating . . . how typically should you alter the batteries?

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

Not like Jaguar, Lexus mounts a full-frontal gizmo assault, significantly with the elective Potentate bundle ($11,320) that turns the again seat into hedonist heaven. There is a energy slider that places you into recline, heaters and coolers within the cushion, a tingler/tickler someplace within the backrest to offer you that Magic Fingers therapeutic massage, plus cup holders, window shades, mild dimmers, door closers, a fridge, your individual back-seat air conditioner, and—are you prepared?—an “optical deodorizer.” We forgot to check it! Nicely, the again seat is simply not our promised land.

But when Dick Grasso is shopping for, sure, thanks, we’ll have one in Cypress Pearl, and have his folks name our folks as quickly because it’s prepared.

THE VERDICT: The subsequent step up from silk underwear.

2004 Lexus LS430
290-hp V-8, 6-speed automated, 4271 lb
Base/as-tested value: $55,750/$70,380
Inside quantity, F/R/trunk: 57/48/18 ft3
60 mph: 6.3 sec
100 mph: 16.4 sec
1/4 mile: 14.9 sec @ 95 mph
Braking, 70­–0 mph: 179 ft
Roadholding, 300-ft-dia skidpad: 0.73 g
C/D noticed gas financial system: 21 mpg

Who Requested for the Lawyer Display screen?

Not one of the automobiles on this check gives you full management till you agree with their firm attorneys. In some, you have to accomplish that each time you begin up. The display screen opens with a warning that such units in automobiles are unholy distractions. It’s essential to click on on “I agree.”

Navigation programs work finest after they present you the place to go; which means some form of show.

Does every other in-car function want such detailed visuals? In all probability not (neglect e-mail in automobiles). But the most recent luxo crop has develop into display screen dependent, to the purpose of ruination within the 7-series BMW.

“It would not be that unhealthy in the event that they modified a number of issues.” That is from the workers’s most ardent 745i defender. The vast majority of us assume iDrive, as BMW calls its pc interface, wants a clean-sheet redesign.

Aaron KileyAutomobile and Driver

BMW tried to take over management of HVAC, audio, chassis settings, journey data, navigation, and so forth., with a display screen. You make your selections with a single knob that turns, toggles, and clicks; it is a mouse substitute. Worse but, the corporate compelled abnormal controls into some contortion of the knob factor; for instance, you have to choose the a part of the seat you wish to regulate by urgent a button, then twist or toggle a knob to make it transfer. Okay, however what was unsuitable with the previous manner?

The truth is, the 745i has buttons and rockers scattered in regards to the sprint that allow you to regulate HVAC and do very fundamental radio/CD adjustments with out utilizing iDrive. However they’re so haphazard of their logic that they solely add to the annoyance.

We have given iDrive 18 months to steer us. It failed. Now the F is in ink. Fearless prediction: The 745i will take a beating on resale.

BMW’s pickle is made worse by the truth that it is all by itself on the irritating excessive. The Jaguar and the Lexus are very pleasant; they’ve contact screens, certainly the simplest enter methodology, and so they present full HVAC and leisure management with out the display screen. The truth is, you needn’t agree with their attorneys if you happen to do not use the navigation.

Audi and VW are virtually as screen-centric as BMW, however they’ve a essential enchancment: Separate buttons, well-labeled, deliver up the assorted menus. Their graphics are additionally vastly superior to BMW’s. We discover them comparatively straightforward to function, significantly the VW’s.

Like Jaguar and Lexus, Mercedes does not drive you to make use of the system for trivial jobs, however the fundamental controls function on their very own quirky logic.

The attorneys are proper: Screens are distracting. And the friendliest automobiles depend upon them the least. —PB

This content material is created and maintained by a 3rd get together, and imported onto this web page to assist customers present their e mail addresses. You could possibly discover extra details about this and related content material at